All Articles

From the Conversation

Being Good Isn’t a Reason to Choose You

Mike Cassidy and Ben Davis on Untrapped Entrepreneur

Mike Cassidy built a capable business that looked like its competitors. His customers gave him a price problem. Listening to them revealed a different way to compete.

Mike Cassidy had customers encouraging him to start a company.

He had already run a manufacturing business. He knew how to deliver. He understood what competitors offered and worked to make sure his new operation had no obvious gaps.

Then he was ready for the orders.

The customers who had encouraged him now saw a new supplier asking them to take a risk. They already had people making similar products. If Mike wanted their business, they expected a lower price.

He needed their orders more than they needed him.

That is an uncomfortable place to find yourself after building something you believe is good. It also explains a trap that can survive excellent execution: if customers cannot see a meaningful reason to choose you, price becomes an easy way to make the decision.

A capable business can still be interchangeable

Mike describes that first version of his company as a “me too” supplier. He had studied competitors and matched what they did. He had not established a difference that mattered enough to buyers.

The relationships were real. So were the customers’ existing alternatives. Knowing Mike did not remove the risk of changing suppliers or create a business case for paying him more.

I see a version of this in services, too. As soon as someone puts your business into a familiar category, a familiar price can follow. If they think they are buying exactly what they already understand, you spend the rest of the conversation explaining the difference.

Mike’s way forward began with a different question. What would customers actually lose if his company went away?

That question is worth sitting with before rewriting your pitch. A convenient option and a valuable partner occupy very different places in a customer’s business.

Ask questions that can change your mind

Mike stopped treating every conversation as a request for an order. He developed a habit of asking, listening and learning.

Why had a customer chosen him for a particular order? What did his company do well? What was frustrating? Why did the customer buy from a competitor, and what did that competitor get wrong? What was the customer planning next?

The answers gave him more than testimonials. They revealed where his assumptions were wrong, where competitors were useful and where an unsolved problem might create an opportunity.

He remembers being proud of showing customers the factory and explaining how things were made. A customer made it clear that the tour was not the point. The customer needed good products delivered when promised.

The work that impresses us inside our company may be necessary without being the reason somebody buys.

Choose two current customers and have a conversation you are willing to learn from. Ask what they value, what they would change and what they are trying to accomplish. Give them room to say something you did not expect. Then compare their answers with the promises you emphasize in your sales materials.

Solve a problem beyond the next order

One of Mike’s strongest examples came from slow payments.

His customers carried large amounts of inventory because they needed to fulfill retail orders reliably. That stock tied up cash. Simply asking to be paid faster did not address what was causing the problem.

His team worked on changing manufacturing equipment over much faster, which let them produce smaller runs. Customers could order closer to what they had actually sold instead of holding so much inventory.

That changed the conversation. Mike could help a customer release cash tied up in stock while also creating a better chance of being paid on time.

In another example, his company expanded into warehousing and distribution after learning that customers were paying to move products from his factory to outside warehouses. Understanding that cost revealed another way the company could help.

These were changes to the offer and the operation. A better slogan alone would not have created the same value.

Make the difference work economically

Mike’s phrase is “Be Different in What Matters.” The important part is whose definition of “matters” you are using.

A feature your team loves may carry little weight with a buyer. A service that seems ordinary to you may solve a costly problem for that customer. You have to learn the difference, then work out whether you can deliver it profitably.

Mike describes bringing customers into the development process early. Instead of building an idea and then trying to sell it, he asks for feedback while the idea can still change. His team considers costs, pricing and delivery as it learns what customers want.

There is no reason to assume every suggestion deserves a new product or service. Test the demand and the economics before making a commitment. The useful difference is one the customer values and the business can sustain.

Give customers a reason to miss you

Mike eventually sold the business to his management team. He later spent 15 years teaching entrepreneurship at Purdue and wrote The Profitable Entrepreneur.

Looking back, the change he values is the move from being another supplier to being a company customers could not imagine operating without.

You do not need to redesign your entire business this week. Start with one customer conversation. Find one assumption that needs testing and one problem you understand better after listening.

Then ask whether solving that problem would give the customer a stronger reason to choose you than a lower price.

Watch the full conversation with Mike Cassidy →